Cafe Muse | Grilled Cheese Sandwich

This has been a staple at my house growing up for forever. I initially thought it was kinda strange putting honey on a grilled cheese sandwich, but it adds a ton of flavor. This is definitely one of my favorite sandwiches.

grilled cheese sandwich on plate with tomato and basil

Recipe courtesy of Greg Reyner at Café Muse, From the show Oprah’s Sandwich Showdown

Serves 1


Set oven to broil. Butter bread on one side with melted butter.

Place in pan, butter side down, over medium-low heat.

Place mozzarella on one half of the bread and fontina and havarti on the other.

Cook until golden on bottom and cheese begins to melt.

Place tomato on mozzarella side and honey on fontina/havarti side.

Place under broiler for a few minutes to heat up tomato.

Sprinkle basil and assemble sandwich.

Café Muse’s Grilled Cheese Sandwich